Skip to main content

Fisk

Robert Fisk has a magnum opus out and it has been reviewed to my liking in this week's DAWN. The title is The Great War for Civilisation: The Conquest of the Middle East (ISBN 1-84115-007-X). Some of the excerpts from the review point towards the nature of the content and I must say they are interesting enough to make the book reach my wishlist.
...As a war correspondent, Fisk has covered every war during the last 30 years in the Middle East and on its periphery from Afghanistan, Algeria and Nagorno-Karabakh to the Islamic heartland between the Gulf and the Mediterranean, a land drenched with blood: the countless Israeli raids into Lebanon, including the 1982 invasion, the Lebanese civil war, Hafez al Assads crackdown on Muslim Brothers in Hama, the Iranian revolution, the Iran-Iraq war, the Kuwait war, Hizbollahs resistance to Israel in south Lebanon and the Iraq war. It is a personal account of the wars juxtaposed with history...
...Fisks magnum opus is more than a history of modern Middle East, as his powerful pen churns out page after page of what looks like a gripping novel, with war, diplomacy, espionage, adventure, history and drama all rolled into one...
...The theme he returns to time and again is the moral bankruptcy of the Wests policy toward the Muslim world since the collapse of the Ottoman empire and the deceit inherent in the incompatibility between the Sykes-Picot pact and the Balfour declaration on the one hand and the promises made to the Hashemites on the other. That duplicity, he avers, has continued till this day and is to be seen in Americas blind support to Israel and the attack on Iraq...

Some corrections need to be made
...There is no God but Allah and Muhammad is His Prophet is not the first sentence of the Koran (p 758). In fact, such a verse is not to be found anywhere in the holy book. The nearest verse is in Sura 48 (Fathh), which says Muhammad is Allahs prophet (verse 29). Also the name of the Arab general at Qadsiya was not Ibn Ali Waqas but Ibn Abi Waqas (p 251). Pakistans poet-philosopher Allama Mohammad Iqbal was born at Sialkot not Surkhot (p 1062), it should be foreign not home secretary (p 1147); the year should be 1917 not 1918 (p 1193), the name Abu Zaher (p 351) needs to be checked. It could be Abu Dhar...

You can read the full review here.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Learning Arduino 1

This holiday season I decided to gift myself some basic electrical components in the form of a Arduino UNO set from Elegoo. I have always had a desire to tinker with electronics and in gifting myself this basic set I am now starting on a journey to quench my inner electrical workman's thirst. I hope to develop this hobby as I move forward and will, from time to time, post about it here on the blog. As the journey moves forward I am sure to run into trouble and issues. But as they say you can not master anything without first being a fool at it, so I have decided to remain a fool at it until I am a little good at it. To start with, I do possess some elementary knowledge in electronics and electronic circuits. I intend to further my knowledge using the world wide web and following some very useful video channels on youtube. I will first start with some very basic projects to familiarize myself with Arduino and basic electronic circuits and techniques such as soldering. Then graduall...
Post a Comment
Read more

Elections 08 V

In the election results of the year 33 former ministers who were closely associated with Musharraf have lost their seats. PML-Q has suffered losses to the seats of those who were stalwarts of the previous administration and were thought to be close to Musharraf himself. the results express more so a disgust and hatred with Musharraf and anything even closely related to him. Otherwise PML-Q has been able to win seats of those members who were not closely associated with Musharraf. So we can safely conclude that this is a an anti Musharraf vote and not a pro PPP or PML-N or ANP vote. In other news the Govt. is now thinking of letting go of the Chief Justice of Pakistan who has been kept under illegal house arrest since November 3, 2007. Aitizaz Ahsan was freed not until the last minutes before election and now Chief Justice's imminent freedom spell something very fishy. What was so important about him that he was not released before elections? What special situation has arise...
Post a Comment
Read more

Pakistan Earthquake

It was terrifying to say the least. We have often heard the proverb being used again and again but this one was a real earth mover. It occurred at about 52 minutes past 8 in the morning while most of our urban population was still asleep in their homes. The jolts kept on coming for about a minute and 10 seconds and then there were lighter jolts in the evening. I was fulfilling my new found glory in the field of gardening when our tractor started shaking like mad. It was literally heaving its huge heavy body sideways like some shaky pendulum.    Then my father called in and told me that the quake had been hard on Rawalpindi and Islamabad. I talked to my relatives there to ensure that they were safe and away from harm's way. Afterwards I switched on the Television. Thus starts my cynicism for the whole event!    The anchor on the TV was so disturbed that he could not even tell the story right. At one point in time he is telling us all the reports fro...
Post a Comment
Read more